Syriza supporters celebrate the results of the exit polls. |
With Syriza marching to an historic victory in the Greek elections, the reaction from New Zealand's left wing blogs has been subdued. It has exposed
again just how conservative and uninspiring much of the New Zealand left has become.
WITH SYRIZA triumphing in the Greek elections, an outside observer might of reasonably expected that New Zealand's left wing blogs would of been excited about the
result. After all, this is a major victory not only for the Greek and the European left but for the left generally. Parties like Podemos in Spain are waiting in the wings to springboard from Syriza's success. No one can now assume
that neoliberalism will remain dominant.
But the reaction on 'left wing' blogs like The Standard and The Daily Blog has been subdued. There has barely been any coverage of Syriza at all.
The lack of comment on Syriza could be argued to be the result of the parochial nature of the blogosphere. While it is true that it concentrates
on local issues that does not preclude coverage of overseas issues and events. Just recently there was extensive comment and analysis of the terrorist attacks in France.
The lack of any real enthusiasm for Syriza can be explained by much of the New Zealand left's continued myopic support for the right wing Labour Party. It refuses
to recognise that Labour is a lost cause and the way to beat conservative forces in New Zealand is to build a genuinely independent and left wing alternative.
Syriza has resoundingly proved that it can be done. In startling contrast the Pasok Party (Greek's version of our Labour Party) has collapsed. Along with
the right wing New Democracy Party it dominated Greek politics for over three decades. Now it is struggling to muster barely four percent of the total vote - it is widely reviled by the Greek people for corruption and
for accepting hated austerity polices while in power in 2009.
Is this what Labour's dwindling number of supporters fear might be the fate of their party? With Labour's electoral support ebbing away, the formation
of a new left out of the rubble of an old and discredited left is not only the realistic option but is what will inevitably happen.
After a deafening silence The Daily Blog finally saw fit to mention Syriza this morning. Unfortunately the job went to editor Martyn Bradbury. After loudly
supporting the Labour Party at the 2014 election his lukewarm enthusiasm for Syriza can only be described as cynical and opportunistic. The leader of Syriza, Alexis Tsipras, is a socialist. Bradbury doesn't like socialists
or socialism. Last year he described socialists as 'unhappy people'.
The blog that he controls will continue to support Labour. As will The Standard. As will the Unite Union. As will the International Socialist Organisation. As will Fightback.
As will Socialist Aotearoa. As will the Council of Trade Unions. Like most of the New Zealand left, they'll all be calling for a vote for Labour in 2017. Are you inspired and excited? No, neither am I.
We deserve a lot better. We deserve our own Syriza.
"The lack of any real enthusiasm for Syriza can be explained by much of the New Zealand left's continued myopic support for the right wing Labour Party."
ReplyDeleteAgree
"The blog that he controls will continue to support Labour. As will The Standard. As will the Unite Union. As will the International Socialist Organisation. As will Socialist Aotearoa. As will the Council of Trade Unions Like most of the New Zealand left, they'll all be calling for a vote for Labour in 2017."
False: The Daily Blog quite clearly supported Internet-Mana and was quick to criticise both Labour and the Greens. The feeling I get from the Standard is quite clearly in support for Labour with the Greens under control out the back. I think attempting to build a new left-wing party was tried and failed with the Internet-Mana experiment, which, thanks to Dotcom, was never going get significant ground.
By no stretch of the imagination was Internet-Mana a left wing party, unless you think making opportunistic deals with the wallet of a German capitalist is 'left wing'. I remind you that Dotcom was happy to financially back an arch-right winger like John Banks.
ReplyDeleteIt is true that The Daily Blog supported Internet Mana. What you don't say is that it saw Internet Mana as part of a Labour-led govt. The Daily Blog's backers - like the Unite Union - urged people to vote for a Labour Govt, despite the fact that Labour was committed - and still is - to maintaining the neoliberal consensus.
Groups like the International Socialist Organisation and Fightback still think it is 1983 and argue Labour is still 'the lesser' evil'. The fact that Labour's support continues to decline and nearly a million New Zealanders no longer vote - because they rightly think it will make no difference - is more evidence of how most of the New Zealand left, in its fixation with Labour, is failing ordinary people.